November 28, 2005
The Detainees are Props in the Terror Game
The Grave Threat of the Bush Administration
By PAUL CRAIG ROBERTS
According to news reports, at a US Naval Academy speech on Wednesday,
President Bush will announce plans for withdrawing US troops from
Iraq. It will be diverting to watch the propagandists at Fox "news"
flip-flop with the White House line and explain that now is the time
to cut and run after all.
A month ago the administration's line was that cutting and running was
the dastardly act of cowards and traitors who would abandon our troops
and all they have fought for. A month ago senior US commanders in Iraq
said that the US-trained new Iraqi army only had 700 troops who could
operate independently of US support.
Now suddenly the new Iraq has the troops to do the job and America's
soldiers can come home. What this means is that Republican pollsters
have made it clear that the Republicans cannot win next year's
congressional elections if the US is still mired in Iraq. The war is
unpopular. A large majority of Americans do not believe the war was
justified, and they no longer support it. Republicans have no prospect
of rehabilitating Bush if he keeps the country bogged down in a
pointless war.
The war, in other words, no longer serves the Republicans' political
interest and must be got rid of. So much for "staying the course."
What will happen to Iraq and the Middle East no one knows. Our
concerns need to be directed at what happens here in the US. Bush's
war against Iraq might be over, but the police state Bush built at
home is still in place.
On November 27 Walter Pincus reported in the Washington Post that the
Pentagon is expanding its domestic surveillance activity and that all
sorts of proposals are afoot to allow military agencies to spy on
law-abiding Americans and to build secret dossiers on citizens. The
demand for police state powers is said to be necessary in order to
fight the "war on terror."
Considering the drastic gestapo-type activities for which Washington
is clamoring, a person would think that America is being overwhelmed
by terrorist attacks. Yet, despite an aggressive and brutal war that
Bush has been waging in Iraq for going on three years, terrorist
attacks in America are even more rare than a honest politician. There
has not been a terror attack since September 11, 2001, more than four
years ago!
The Bush administration's hype about terrorism serves no purpose other
than to build a police state that is far more dangerous to Americans
than terrorists.
Ever since the "war on terror" was initiated by the Bush
administration, the US has been holding large numbers of "detainees."
By chance or the laws of probability, a few of these people might fit
some definition of "terrorist." The vast majority, however, are
innocents picked up in the equivalent of Stalin-era KGB street sweeps.
Many are hapless people sold by warlords to the US in order to receive
cash awards for turning in "terrorists."
Despite the large number of alleged "terrorists" or "enemy combatants"
that are being held, the Bush administration simply hasn't a shred of
evidence with which to bring "detainees" to trial.
If truth be known, the "detainees" are merely props for Bush's hype
about the "terrorist threat." The "detainees" were arrested in order
to make Americans feel safe and at ease with the police state.
Perhaps the most famous of the alleged terrorists, a man held for more
than three years, is the "dirty bomber" Jose Padilla. Padilla was the
"grave threat" who was going to set off a radioactive dirty bomb in a
US city.
The charge never made any sense. If al Qaeda had a dirty bomb, they
certainly would not entrust it to the loud-mouthed Padilla, who was
being followed around by FBI agents. Such a weapon would be kept
secret and entrusted only to the most competent and proven hands.
Who could possibly believe that top al Qaeda operatives would meet and
plot with Jose Padilla?
The Bush administration has itself given up its Padilla fantasy. After
three years of hype about this most dangerous of terrorists who
allegedly intended to kill large numbers of Americans, the
government's indictment doesn't mention dirty bombs or the murder of
Americans. Instead, Padilla is indicted for conspiring "to commit at
any place outside the United States acts that would constitute murder"
for the purpose of advancing "violent jihad." Padilla is also charged
with "conspiracy to provide material support for terrorists."
In other words, the government has no case against Padilla and is
putting him on trial in the US for conspiring to kill unidentified
foreigners in an effort to overthrow an unidentified foreign country.
His case is lumped in with a case against four other persons, one or
more of whom may have committed an actual crime that can be used to
tar them all.
Both the Attorney General and President of the United States branded
Padilla a "grave threat" to the lives of Americans. After three years
of this propaganda, all the US government can come up with is the
trumped up charge of conspiracy to kill foreigners and to provide
support for terrorists.
A police state has to catch enemies in order to keep the people
frightened and appreciative of the watchful eye of the police state.
Now that the Padilla case has evaporated, the Bush administration has
come up with a replacement. An American student of Arab descent, who
was studying at a Saudi Arabian university, has been indicted by a
federal grand jury for conspiracy to assassinate President Bush. The
indictment rests on the confession wrung out of the young man by
torture in a Saudi prison.
Does anyone really believe that al Qaeda leaders would conspire with
an American college student to assassinate President Bush? Indeed,
President Bush has been Osama bin Laden's greatest benefactor. Why
would al Qaeda want to kill the man who is doing them so much good?
Before Bush launched his war on terror and invaded Iraq, the vast
majority of Muslims thought bin Laden was a nut case and supported the
US. Today Muslims think Bush is a nut case and support bin Laden.
What kind of a country have we become when we put a citizen on trial
on the basis of a confession obtained under torture by a foreign
government? Is the case against this student anything other than an
attempt to enlist the sympathy factor for Bush in order to repair his
standing in the polls?
Americans need to understand that a police state has to produce
results in order to justify its budget and its powers. It doesn't
really care who it catches. Stalin's police state caught the wife of
Stalin's foreign minister in one of its street sweeps.
The Bush administration justifies torture and threatens to veto
congressional attempts to restrain its use. The Bush administration
justifies indefinite detention of American citizens without charges.
It asserts the power of indefinite detention based on its subjective
judgment about who is a threat. An American government that preaches
"freedom and democracy" to the world claims the powers of tyrants as
its own.
Americans need to wake up. The only danger to Americans in Iraq is the
one Bush created by invading the country. The grave threat that
Americans face is the Bush administration's police state mentality.
Paul Craig Roberts has held a number of academic appointments and has
contributed to numerous scholarly publications. He served as Assistant
Secretary of the Treasury in the Reagan administration. His graduate
economics education was at the University of Virginia, the University
of California at Berkeley, and Oxford University. He is coauthor of
The Tyranny of Good Intentions. He can be reached at:
paulcraigroberts@yahoo.com
***
Democracy is a form of religion. It is the worship of jackals by jackasses.
- H.L. Mencken
www.soundclick.com/pseudojandek
jackal music for jackass people
------------------------ Yahoo! Groups Sponsor --------------------~-->
Get fast access to your favorite Yahoo! Groups. Make Yahoo! your home page
http://us.click.yahoo.com/dpRU5A/wUILAA/yQLSAA/9rHolB/TM
--------------------------------------------------------------------~->
Yahoo! Groups Links
<*> To visit your group on the web, go to:
http://groups.yahoo.com/group/CanYoAssDigIt/
<*> To unsubscribe from this group, send an email to:
CanYoAssDigIt-unsubscribe@yahoogroups.com
<*> Your use of Yahoo! Groups is subject to:
http://docs.yahoo.com/info/terms/
No comments:
Post a Comment